The principle of separate legal personality remains the golden rule of company law, solicitor Dr Tom Courtney has said.
However, this did not necessarily protect directors or parent companies from all liability and “alternative director liability” was gaining momentum, he warned.
“Salomon v Salomon established that a company is a separate legal entity. Its assets are its assets. Its liabilities are its liabilities,” Courtney told the Law Society Business Committee Annual Conference (11 November).
Cornerstone
“That's the golden rule, and it actually is the cornerstone upon which so much of our corporate law is based,” he added.
Dr Courtney said he believed it was important that Irish courts continued to respect and vindicate the principle, because knowing a jurisdiction did so in all but exceptional circumstances was one of the principles that “gives our clients a warm, fuzzy feeling”.
Powers v Greymountain Management Ltd [2022] IEHC 599 was the first time an Irish court lifted the corporate veil in a fraud involving shadow directors and formal directors who had abrogated their responsibilities, but this was, and should be, “very much an outlier”.
‘Lifting the corporate veil’ refers to where a court disregards the company’s separate legal personality and holds those in control of the company accountable for its actions or liabilities.
“It is the court stepping in to provide an extraordinary remedy in circumstances that the legislature hasn't really thought of,” he explained.
Fiduciary duties
Regarding other avenues of holding directors accountable, Courtney said that there had been too much emphasis on fiduciary duties when there was a broader range of potential liabilities, particularly in tort and criminal law.
In Lifestyle Equities CV v Ahmed [2024] UKSC 17, the British Supreme Court made clear that a director's liability for their own tortious conduct was not a matter of lifting the corporate veil.
A company and its director are separate legal persons, and both may be liable for the same wrongdoing.
Courtney said that it came as a surprise to him that there was no rule that directors acting in the ordinary course of the discharge of their duties were completely insulated from personal tort liability.
However, when researching it, he discovered that the principle had also been recognised in the Irish Court of Appeal in Kelly v Clarion Quay Management Company CLG [2021] IECA 162.
Deliberate acts
The court found that there must be evidence of the individual's own involvement, and Courtney suggested that the issue was particularly relevant to deliberate acts such as trespass, intellectual-property infringement, and defamation.
In a panel discussion, MHC consultant Justin McKenna said he too had been surprised by the Lifestyle Equities verdict.
“I think it is going to have to result in a change in the way directors are advised,” he said, raising a hypothetical example of directors of a property company becoming personally exposed in connection with the eviction of tenants.
Extent of liability
Courtney acknowledged that the extent of this potential liability remains uncertain.
The law of tort still requires the claimant to establish the necessary elements – including a duty of care and foreseeability; personal liability is not automatic merely because someone is a director.
Directors also need to be mindful of liability under criminal law.
“I'm not just talking about officer in default,” he explained, “every single statute on the statute books legislates for the possibility that whatever offence is created by that statute will be committed by a company, and it expressly provides that the directors of the company can be prosecuted where they consent, or they connive, or they are neglectful.”
He noted too that, under competition law, a company did not have to be prosecuted for the directors to be prosecuted.
The possibility of liability arising from the use of AI systems also raises questions, although Courtney cautioned that any claim would still have to satisfy the ordinary requirements of the relevant cause of action.
Another developing area to which Dr Courtney drew attention is the potential liability of parent companies for harm arising from the activities of their subsidiaries.
This did not require the corporate veil to be lifted, he said; the matter in question was whether the parent company had itself assumed a duty of care under ordinary negligence principles.
Vedanta Resources plc v Lungowe [2019] UKSC 20 and Okpabi v Royal Dutch Shell plc [2021] UKSC 3, and AAA & Others v Unilever PLC involved subsidiaries in underdeveloped or developing countries whose indigenous people alleged wrongdoing.
Relevant factors include the extent to which the business has taken over or jointly managed operations, issued advice or group policies, and taken steps to ensure that those policies are implemented.
Courtney pointed out that activities that might ordinarily be regarded as examples of good group governance could also provide the basis for a finding of a duty of care.
The Okpabi case in Nigeria is due to go to trial on 5 May next year and will be watched closely, as its outcome could help shape the law in this area.
In the panel discussion, moderator Eleanor Daly of Meta (pictured) pointed out that the requirements of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), whereby companies establish and report on group-wide environmental, social and governance arrangements, could create evidence relevant to a claim that a parent had assumed responsibility for a subsidiary's operations.
Shareholder rule
Courtney also flagged a development in the so-called shareholder rule, under which shareholders can in certain circumstances claim access to legal advice obtained by their company.
In Globoforce Group plc v Luxembourg Investment Company 276 SARL, the High Court held that the rule had no place in Irish law.
Dr Courtney suggested that the practical effect may be limited, since an exception already applied where litigation was in being or contemplated.
However, in non-contentious situations, the decision means shareholders cannot simply assume that legal advice obtained by the company is available to them.